By Michael Hopewell (Intern, IHC)
February 28, 2013
This past month, the Water Institute at the University of North Carolina, Chapel Hill (UNC), estimated that 4.1 billion people lack access to adequate sanitation facilities, a number that is much higher than the United Nation’s Joint Monitoring Program’s estimate of 2.5 billion. The discrepancy between the figures lies in how “adequate” is defined by each party when measuring sanitation access. While the UN measures hardware – toilet, latrine, or lack thereof – and how well it protects the user from contact with waste, UNC researchers focused on whether the waste was treated before it reentered the environment.
This disagreement in definition highlights the difficulty of categorizing access to water and sanitation, which is multifaceted, seasonal, and geographically variable, into a binary ‘access’ or ‘no access’.
Measuring treatment ensures that when a person achieves traditional “improved” sanitation facilities – perhaps gaining access to a latrine with a washable slab cover – they are not forgotten. Instead they can strive to achieve even higher levels of sanitation such as treatment of the waste.
On the other hand this higher standard might neglect the measurable health benefits of incremental improvements in sanitation facilities, before waste treatment systems are available. And while ambitious, it is unrealistic to believe that comprehensive sewerage systems that treat waste are a realistic, immediate solution everywhere.
How we measure access to water and sanitation in the short-term won’t necessarily be the standard for how we eventually define universal access. But as discussions around the post-2015 development goals continue, discussing these differences and defining exactly what adequate sanitation means is absolutely necessary.
Read more about UNC’s Water Institute here.