By Matt Seamon (Intern, IHC)
July 17, 2013
The recent explosion of population growth in large cities all around the developing world presents opportunities for economic development, but it has also exacerbated the issue of urban slums. Slums, which are generally characterized by insecure land tenure, extensive overcrowding, squalid living conditions, and a lack of municipal services like water and sanitation, are a massive public health problem. Many cities have increasingly taken steps to eliminate slums by razing slum buildings and replacing them with rapidly constructed residential housing blocks designed to absorb excess population. However, the promotion of hastily-constructed new buildings has produced its own dangers for the urban poor.
That is the focus of an op-ed published last week in the New York Times. The article documents a recent wave of building collapses in the slums around Mumbai, including a collapse that killed 74 people in April and another this month that killed at least six people and injured more than two dozen. In both cases, the root cause was shoddy construction work and dangerously low-quality building materials. In the rush to develop additional real estate, new buildings are neither approved nor overseen by any government agency. In the absence of regulations, and with an ever-worsening housing shortage brought on by Mumbai’s booming population, new construction emphasizes ease and affordability over safety and stability. The result: “shoddily built disasters.”
The op-ed puts the responsibility squarely on the city government, which has implemented faulty urban policies and allowed unrestrained real-estate speculation. The authors call on the city to re-think their current approach and look to other cities that have successfully upgraded their urban infrastructure as inspiration for new policies. They argue that Mumbai “will not solve its overcrowding problems by promoting buildings that could become lethal liabilities in the near future.”
Above all, the op-ed—and the tragic situation in Mumbai—highlight how important municipal governments and comprehensive urban planning are to global economic development and poverty reduction. The full article, titled “Boom and Bust at the Same Time,” can be found here.